Most L&D teams struggle to prove their value. Here are three ways to change that
David James, Chief Learning Officer at 360Learning, uses 1,062 maturity self-assessments to show L&D leaders three practical ways to prove the value of their work.

L&D teams have a huge opportunity to play a more strategic role in their organisations, helping businesses develop the skills they need and improve performance. But how close are we to achieving that?
At 360Learning, we analysed 1,062 self-assessments against our Maturity Model, covering seven themes and five levels, from ‘Reactive’ to ‘Transformative’.
The headline? 85% sit at Levels 2 or 3. Fewer than one in ten reach Levels 4 or 5.
The EmEx newsletter
Get one practical EX read every Wednesday
Join the HR and employee experience leaders who read EmEx each week. It is free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
These findings show that most L&D teams have a solid foundation. They’re delivering programmes, engaging employees and supporting development across their organisations. The opportunity now is to build on that work and connect it more closely to the outcomes businesses care about.
Because ultimately, business leaders don’t just want to know how much learning we’ve delivered. They want to know what’s changed as a result.
This isn’t about L&D teams failing. It’s about recognising where we can go further, particularly in demonstrating the impact of our work. And as AI changes the skills organisations need, there’s never been a more important time for L&D to step up and help businesses prepare for what’s next.
Improving doesn’t necessarily require a complete overhaul. Here are three places to start.
1. Take stock of what’s working and what’s not
Only 3.5% of teams scored the same across all seven themes, from learning strategy to leadership alignment. And 61% had a gap of two levels or more between their strongest and weakest areas.
Most teams excel in some areas but struggle in others. Rather than trying to fix everything, we need to identify what’s holding us back.
Is your L&D strategy something senior leadership actively backs, or simply approves? Are you solving business problems, or responding to requests for courses? Can you show what changed because of your work?
A team might deliver excellent learning but lack the influence to shape its priorities. Another might have leadership backing though struggles to prove its value.
Knowing which problem you have is the first step towards addressing it. Otherwise, we’re doing more of the same and hoping for a different result.
2. Think beyond the annual training plan
The most commonly cited weakness was identifying learning needs, with 52% of respondents struggling in this area.
If we don’t understand what people need to be able to do, how can we be confident we’re developing the right capabilities?
Too often, L&D plans are built around requests from leaders or assumptions about employees’ needs, rather than what’s preventing people from performing.
AI makes that approach increasingly difficult to justify. Jobs and skills are changing faster than annual training plans can keep up with. If we’re reacting to last year’s needs, we’re already behind.
In my experience, people closest to the work spot gaps first. L&D teams should speak regularly with line managers and employees, alongside senior leaders, to understand where work gets stuck and what capabilities are missing.
We also need to look ahead. What is the business trying to achieve over the next year or two? What skills will people need? Where are we exposed?
That’s how L&D moves from responding to training requests to building the capabilities the organisation needs.
3. Stop measuring activity and start measuring impact
Measurement was the lowest-scoring theme, with nearly two-thirds (63%) of respondents at Levels 1 or 2.
We’ve relied too long on course completions, attendance and satisfaction scores to demonstrate success. These metrics have their place, but they tell us what people did, not what improved. That’s where L&D can lose credibility.
Teams reaching Levels 4 or 5 for measurement had an average overall maturity score of 3.62, compared with 2.21 for those at Levels 1 or 2. That doesn’t prove a link, but it’s striking.
The answer is to start with the business problem, not the learning programme.
Before developing a solution, agree with leaders what needs to change. Are new employees taking too long to become productive? Are costly errors affecting performance? Then decide how you’ll measure improvement.
If we can show that developing skills reduced time to better performance or addressed a critical capability gap, we’re having a different conversation with leadership.
Ultimately, L&D doesn’t need to prove people are learning. We need to prove learning helps the organisation achieve what it couldn’t before. That’s how we become a function the business cannot afford to overlook.
David James is Chief Learning Officer at 360Learning. You can find 360Learning’s The State of L&D Maturity Report here.

