Why a speak-up culture needs more than an open-door policy
The recent resignation of Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon has brought renewed attention to what happens when employees feel unable to challenge decisions within their organisation. While the circumstances are specific to the AI industry, the wider issue matters to every business: Employees are often the first to spot emerging risks, question decisions, or recognise when…

The recent resignation of Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon has brought renewed attention to what happens when employees feel unable to challenge decisions within their organisation. While the circumstances are specific to the AI industry, the wider issue matters to every business: Employees are often the first to spot emerging risks, question decisions, or recognise when something is not working. But whether those concerns reach the people who can act on them depends on how an organisation is structured and led.
For HR and people leaders, the challenge is not simply encouraging employees to speak up. It is about ensuring trusted routes to raise concerns, clear responsibilities for responding, and confidence that challenging a decision will not damage an employee’s career. An open-door policy is a starting point, but it is no substitute for creating an environment where speaking up is part of everyday business.
Give employees clear routes to raise concerns
The EmEx newsletter
Get one practical EX read every Wednesday
Join the HR and employee experience leaders who read EmEx each week. It is free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Most organisations have reporting processes, whether through line managers, HR teams or confidential channels. However, having these in place does not necessarily mean employees understand how to use them or trust that they will work.
The first step is making it clear where employees should go when they have a concern, particularly when the issue involves their direct manager or senior leadership. There should always be more than one option. Employees need access to someone outside their immediate reporting line, whether that is a designated HR contact, another senior leader or an independent reporting channel.
Just as importantly, organisations must establish what happens next: Who reviews the concern, how quickly it will be acknowledged, when it should be escalated further, and how the employee will know whether action has been taken. Without clear answers, even well-intentioned reporting processes can become places where concerns disappear rather than get resolved.
HR leaders should regularly review these processes by gathering employee feedback and examining how concerns have been handled. The objective should be to understand whether employees feel heard, rather than simply confirming that procedures have been followed.
Build networks that connect employees and leadership
Another common barrier is the distance between employees who identify problems and the senior leaders responsible for decisions. In larger organisations, concerns may pass through several management layers before reaching someone with the authority to act. Along the way, important context can be lost or issues dismissed before receiving proper consideration.
One way to address this is through a guiding coalition: a group of informally influential people from different departments and levels of seniority who work together to support organisational change. These groups can help strengthen communication between employees and leadership, ensuring decision-makers understand what is happening across the business.
However, their role must go beyond communicating leadership decisions. Members should have the freedom to question assumptions, raise concerns and offer alternative perspectives. Employees should understand who represents their area of the business, how they can contribute and how their feedback reaches senior leaders.
These networks should complement formal reporting channels, particularly where confidential or serious matters are involved. Their purpose is to ensure information moves upwards and across the organisation, rather than relying entirely on traditional management hierarchies.
Make managers responsible for creating safe environments
Even the strongest reporting structures will achieve little if employees believe challenging a decision could negatively affect their careers. This is why psychological safety – the confidence to speak openly without fear of negative consequences – must be treated as a leadership responsibility.
Managers set the tone through everyday interactions. When an employee questions a decision, does their manager listen and ask questions, or immediately become defensive? Are different perspectives welcomed in meetings, or do employees learn that agreement is the safest option? These interactions determine whether people feel comfortable speaking up.
HR leaders can help by making openness and constructive challenge part of how managers are trained, assessed and supported. This could include encouraging managers to seek regular feedback, asking teams to discuss what has not worked following major projects and assessing how leaders respond when employees raise difficult issues.
Senior executives must demonstrate the same behaviours. If leaders publicly encourage openness but privately discourage disagreement, employees will quickly recognise the contradiction. Ultimately, workplace culture is shaped by the behaviours an organisation rewards and tolerates, not simply the values it promotes.
Ask the questions that reveal whether the culture is working
Boards and executive teams also have a responsibility to ensure these practices work across the organisation. Rather than relying solely on employee engagement scores or the number of formal complaints received, they should ask more direct questions:
● Can employees challenge senior leaders without worrying about their careers?
● Do employees know where to turn when their manager is part of the problem?
● How do we know important concerns are reaching the right decision-makers?
● What evidence shows employee feedback has influenced decisions?
● Are managers held accountable for how they respond to criticism?
● When did leadership last change course because an employee raised a concern?
These questions shift attention from whether reporting mechanisms exist to whether they make a meaningful difference. A low number of reported concerns should not automatically be considered positive. It may indicate a healthy workplace, but it could equally suggest employees lack confidence in the systems available to them. Boards must be willing to investigate that distinction and act when weaknesses emerge.
Make speaking up part of everyday business
Employees will not feel safe raising concerns simply because an organisation introduces a policy, training programme or leadership announcement. It requires consistent attention to the structures and behaviours shaping how people work.
Clear escalation routes help concerns reach the right people; networks across the business allow information to travel beyond traditional hierarchies; managers create the conditions for constructive challenge, while boards and executives ensure those expectations are upheld.
For HR leaders, the priority is bringing these elements together so speaking up becomes an established part of how decisions are made, problems are addressed, and change is managed. The measure of success is not whether employees are willing to raise concerns publicly when things go wrong, but whether they have the confidence to raise them internally, knowing they will be taken seriously. Organisations that achieve this will be better equipped to identify risks early, make informed decisions and address problems before they become crises.



