How Onboarding Can Protect New Joiners from Impersonation Scams
Samantha Clarke, Senior Threat Research Engineer at Mimecast, sets out how HR leaders can use onboarding to protect new joiners from impersonation scams.

Starting a new job is exciting, but it’s also uncertain. Learning an organisation’s unwritten rules takes time: who reports to whom, how senior leaders communicate and what a normal request from your boss looks like.
Attackers are exploiting that uncertainty. The latest UK Government Cyber Security Breaches Survey found that 12% of UK businesses reported attempted scams impersonating staff. The financial stakes are high too. Take CEO fraud, where scammers impersonate senior leaders to target employees. UK Finance reported that although these scams are low in volume, they carry the highest average losses, with more than £1.6 million lost in the first half of 2025.
The Cyber Breaches Survey has tracked impersonation scams since 2018, and they’ve had plenty of media attention. So why do they persist? Because awareness in isolation leaves the underlying risk in place. Closing it takes HR leaders and security teams working together to keep guidance up to date as scams evolve, and to build financial request, approval and verification processes that can withstand fraud.
The EmEx newsletter
Get one practical EX read every Wednesday
Join the HR and employee experience leaders who read EmEx each week. It is free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Why new joiners remain a target
Attackers deliberately target new joiners because the first months in a role create a window of vulnerability. Starters are still learning reporting lines, communication norms and who asks for what. They’re also keen to make a good impression, which can make them less likely to question a request that appears to come from a manager.
What makes these scams so effective is that the opening message often contains nothing obviously malicious. An attacker posing as a senior executive may simply welcome the employee and ask if they’re available. Only after the new starter replies does the conversation turn to secrecy and urgency, and eventually a financial request.
HR professionals should understand how new joiners are identified in the first place. Attackers look for public social media announcements and company welcome posts that reveal where someone works, their role and when they started. Mimecast recently found that around nine in ten employees targeted in impersonation scam cases had publicly posted on LinkedIn about starting their job.
The tactics are also evolving. Employees are often taught to be wary of requests to buy Amazon gift cards, but we’ve seen criminals switch to Airbnb and John Lewis vouchers instead, so a warning that is too specific can be sidestepped. The deeper concern is the method. Once an employee believes they’re talking to a trusted colleague, attackers can manipulate them into actions they would otherwise question.
How HR leaders can respond
HR leaders should start by making sure onboarding covers welcome-themed business email compromise (BEC), using scenarios new joiners might genuinely encounter in their first weeks and months.
That training should go beyond generic phishing awareness. It should explain how attackers exploit new employees’ uncertainty around reporting lines and communication norms. Phishing simulations can use new-joiner scenarios and executive impersonation tactics. Onboarding should also set out clear verification steps, including how to confirm an unusual request through a separate channel, such as a phone call or internal chat. By showing how a harmless-looking welcome message can develop into a scam, HR can stop a moment of uncertainty becoming a costly security incident.
A case for joined-up thinking
Awareness is only part of the answer. New employees also need to know what legitimate financial and executive requests look like in their organisation.
HR, finance and security teams should make approval processes explicit during onboarding. Would an executive ever ask an employee to buy gift cards? Who can authorise an unusual purchase? How should a request be independently verified? When those rules are clear from day one, impersonation scams become much harder to pull off.
It’s also worth rethinking what’s shared online about new hires. Welcome posts and company news updates help new employees feel valued, but there is a security trade-off if the details make them easier to identify and target.
Finally, HR has a critical role in making it safe to question unusual requests. New starters may be reluctant to challenge authority figures or admit they’re unsure. Working with security teams, HR should establish clear reporting routes, so employees know exactly where to take a suspicious message and feel supported when they do.
Make onboarding part of your risk strategy
Attackers rely on a simple fact: new employees can’t immediately know all of an organisation’s unwritten rules. Clear processes and a culture of confidence give people the means to pause, verify and challenge an unusual request while they’re still learning the ropes. Done well, onboarding is one of an organisation’s most effective security controls, as well as an HR process.



