Without Trust, Compliance Processes are Ineffective
Whether or not an organisation can claim it is safe and compliant depends on the experience of its employees.

By Erena Langley, Director of Regulatory Solutions, NAVEX
When asked whether their employees feel protected to speak up in the workplace, most businesses will point to their reporting channel, a non-retaliation policy, and open door conversations. However, having these measures in place is merely a confirmation of the structure. Whether or not an organisation can claim it is safe and compliant depends on the experience of its employees.
NAVEX’s 2026 State of Risk & Compliance Report analysed ethics and compliance programmes worldwide to uncover what measures were being put in place and, more importantly, what the implications of those measures are on ensuring employees feel protected.
The EmEx newsletter
Get one practical EX read every Wednesday
Join the HR and employee experience leaders who read EmEx each week. It is free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Organisations are investing in compliance
Today, compliance teams are better resourced than ever before. NAVEX observed a continued investment in speak-up infrastructure, training and awareness initiatives and upgrades to compliance tech. With 93% of businesses expecting to maintain their budgets or increase by as much as 10%; there is no question that the infrastructure is in place.
In line with the Ethics and Compliance Initiative’s High-Quality Program (HQP), NAVEX has observed a growing percentage of organisations whose compliance programmes fall into the two highest categories of maturity. These are a “managing” programme, which is good but not an HQP, or an “optimising” programme, which contains majority, if not all, of the elements of an HQP. In a HQP, reporting channels are more accessible, policies are consistent, oversight mechanisms are formalised, and activity is reported to leadership. Meanwhile, the same report found that capacity also continues to rise with the global average for compliance teams within an organisation of over 100,000 employees reaching 67 team members.
Infrastructure is not enough
So, compliance programmes are better resourced, but infrastructure alone does not determine effectiveness. 59% of compliance programmes with the highest level of maturity continue to report issues, only slightly less than the 66% of programmes with the lowest level of maturity. Similarly, when NAVEX investigated budget as an indicator, the gap between outcomes for organisations with low and high compliance budgets was very modest. Budget may buy extra capacity, but adding headcount does not mandate better outcomes.
Businesses have traditionally relied on structural indicators such as policy distribution, training completion rates, staffing levels and budget allocation to assess whether their compliance programme is effective. While this checklist is an important benchmark as it is aligned with internationally recognised standards like the ISO Risk Management Framework, it is only a checklist.
While ticking off a checklist of compliance infrastructure may give the impression of quality, the processes become redundant if employees do not make use of them. It is combining a mature programme with the right behavioural and cultural conditions that will generate impact.
Employees are not speaking up
Speak-up culture is a critical tool for compliance as employees who feel safe raising concerns can shine a light on issues before they are exacerbated. Businesses are focused on building the components of a speak-up programme – 55% of those surveyed by NAVEX have non-retaliation policies, 55% have anonymous reporting channels, and 51% have regular leadership meetings about speaking up – but they are not always addressing the cultural conditions that make employees feel safe in using them.
Employees may be deterred from participating in a speak-up programme by fear of retaliation if they do and will decide whether to use the system based on what happens after they make a report. 36% of respondents to NAVEX’s survey, for instance, claimed issues raised were not addressed or resolved, 28% said investigations took too long and 30% did not receive a follow-up after raising their concern. Worse, only 40% of organisations have currently trained their managers on how to receive or handle reports.
A truly effective speak-up culture requires continued reinforcement of trust, transparency and accountability. Timely follow-ups and visible actions reassure employees that their concerns are taken seriously. Simply having internal reporting mechanisms in place is insufficient if the target users do not feel safe to use them in the first place.
Lead by example
If having the infrastructure is not a reliable indicator of an effective compliance programme, then what is?
Trust. Employees trusting the compliance systems is what determines whether a programme truly works. One critical mistake eroding trust is inconsistency at the board level. NAVEX uncovered that over a quarter of boards are not consistently engaged in compliance programmes, and amongst those that are engaged only 36% participate in periodic compliance training and only 34% have a designated oversight committee.
Employees notice when compliance is positioned to them as a strategic priority and yet is treated as conditional by senior leadership, only addressed in moments of crisis. It generates uncertainty over expectations and erodes trust in their company’s commitment to ethics. Furthermore, workers may be less willing to elevate a concern if they perceive their leadership to be holding themselves to a different ethical standard.
Learning from cultural indicators
Instead of relying on the presence of structures and processes to determine an effective programme, the quality of compliance should be based on factors that shift focus toward behavioural and cultural indicators.
Factors like whether leaders model ethical behaviour, whether boards move beyond awareness to active oversight, whether employees trust that their concerns will be handled fairly and whether actions taken reinforce the organisation’s stated values.
These measurements all reveal whether a compliance programme is working by connecting a behaviour with its outcome. Notably, most of these responsibilities lie with leadership, their actions are not only cultural but predictive. Many companies that have experienced a compliance failure have not done so because of a lack of policies or control but due to a pattern of behavioural choices. Fostering a culture that prioritises ethical behaviour results in a better protected business.
The data proves that more resources, larger teams and more mature programmes do not correspond with better compliance outcomes. The organisations that come out on top in terms of compliance are therefore not those with the most complex processes and tools in place but those that ensure board oversight translates into meaningful engagement. Compliance messaging must be reflected in action, as employees need evidence, not just assurance, that their employer is doing the right things right.



